The Great Retention: Strategies to Keep Top Talent in the Nonprofit Sector

Nonprofits are facing a retention crisis. Here's what you need to know:

• 37% of staff leave due to low pay
• 33% quit because of limited growth opportunities
• 35% depart feeling undervalued

To keep your best people, focus on:

1. Offering clear growth paths
2. Providing fair compensation and benefits
3. Creating a positive work environment
4. Recognizing good work
5. Implementing mentoring programs
6. Using technology to boost engagement

Investing in retention pays off:

• Lower turnover costs (1/3 of annual salary to replace an employee)
• Improved fundraising (4 years for fundraisers to reach full potential)
• Stronger teams and greater mission impact

Remember: It's not just about money. Create a workplace where people want to stay and grow.

Related video from YouTube

What is employee retention in nonprofits?

Employee retention in nonprofits is keeping staff long-term. It's crucial because nonprofits often face high turnover.

Defining employee retention

It's the rate at which a nonprofit keeps its workers. We measure it by the percentage of staff who stay over time.

Good retention matters for nonprofits. Here's why:

• Cuts costs (replacing staff is expensive)
• Keeps knowledge in-house
• Maintains donor and community relationships

What affects retention

Nonprofits face unique retention challenges:

1. Pay and benefits

Nonprofits often can't match for-profit salaries. This can make staff feel undervalued.

2. Growth opportunities

Staff want career growth. Without clear paths up, they might leave.

3. Mission connection

People join nonprofits to make a difference. Losing that spark can lead to exits.

4. Workload and burnout

Lean operations often mean heavy workloads and burnout.

5. Workplace culture

A positive environment can keep staff engaged despite other issues.

The stats are clear:

• 19% average nonprofit turnover rate
• Nearly half of nonprofit staff plan to job hunt by 2025
• Fundraisers take about 4 years to hit their stride

Michelle Flores Vryn, co-author of a 2024 retention report, notes:

"The top three reasons [for leaving] were having too much responsibility without support, lack of clear pathways for growth, and inadequate compensation and benefits."

Nonprofits that tackle these issues can keep their top talent and build stable teams to drive their mission.

Checking your nonprofit's retention needs

Nonprofits have a staff turnover problem. With a 21% rate, it's time to look at your retention efforts.

Reviewing current strategies

Start with the numbers:

1. Calculate your turnover rate
2. Compare it to the 21% nonprofit average
3. Break down departures by department and role

Then, dig deeper:

• Exit interviews: Why do people leave?
• Stay interviews: Why do others stick around?
• Anonymous surveys: Get the real scoop

Finding weak spots

Look for patterns in your data:

1. Pay and benefits: Are you competitive?
2. Growth opportunities: Can staff move up?
3. Workload: Is burnout an issue?
4. Culture: Do people feel valued?

Watch out for:

• High turnover in specific roles
• Feedback about lack of growth
• Workload or burnout complaints

Don't ignore onboarding. A 2016 Deloitte study found 44% of millennials plan to quit within two years. Good onboarding can change that.

"The top reason for voluntary turnover in nonprofits? Lack of growth opportunities at 59.7%", says a recent sector study.

Take action:

1. Map career paths: Show staff their potential
2. Offer training: Invest in skills
3. Review pay: Adjust if possible
4. Improve work-life balance: Try flexible schedules

sbb-itb-a630d3d

Ways to keep top workers

Nonprofits struggle to retain talent. Here's how to keep your best employees:

Offer growth opportunities

People want to grow. Create clear career paths and help with training. The American Red Cross does this well:

They have a Leadership Development Program that helps staff become managers.

Fair pay and benefits

You can't match for-profit salaries, but you can offer good total compensation:

Build a positive workplace

Focus on your mission and work-life balance. Flexible schedules are huge - staff value this as much as a 10% raise.

Recognize good work

Highlight achievements. It could be a simple "Staff Spotlight" or a yearly awards event.

Provide mentoring and leadership chances

Connect junior staff with leaders. Let employees run projects or committees. It helps them grow.

Use tech to engage staff

Use tools for better communication. Slack can create team channels, building community even for remote workers.

To keep staff, understand what they need. Do regular check-ins and anonymous surveys. As Grayson Williams from Red Hat says:

"We focus on making sure this is a great place to be."

Tracking retention success

Want to keep your best workers? You need to know if your efforts are working. Here's how to measure your nonprofit's retention success:

Measuring retention

Let's start with the basics. Here's how to calculate your retention rate:

1. Count employees at year start
2. Subtract those who left
3. Divide by starting number
4. Multiply by 100

Here's an example:

For nonprofits, aim for above 90%. Below that? Time to step up your game.

But don't stop there. Keep an eye on these too:

• Voluntary turnover rate
• New hire satisfaction
• Average employment length
• Cost of turnover

Many nonprofits use HR software to track these. It's like having a retention radar.

Numbers are great, but they're not everything. Want the full picture? Use surveys and exit interviews. Ask about:

• Job satisfaction
• Growth opportunities
• Work-life balance
• Manager relationships

"We focus on making sure this is a great place to be", says Grayson Williams from Red Hat. They use regular check-ins to catch issues early.

Remember: Happy employees stick around. Keep your finger on the pulse, and you'll keep your best talent.

Solving common retention problems

Nonprofits face unique challenges in keeping their best people. Let's tackle two big issues: burnout and tight budgets.

Preventing burnout

Burnout is a real problem in nonprofits. During COVID-19, 51% of Americans reported mental health issues at work. For nonprofits, it was even worse.

Here's how to spot and stop burnout:

1. Check workloads regularly

Have managers meet with staff often. Ask about projects and stress levels. Help them manage work better.

2. Make work-life balance a priority

Lead by example. Take your vacation days. Encourage others to do the same.

Krista Wilbur from Austin Angels says:

"If your people are burnt out, your organization is burnt out, and that directly impacts your morale, culture, and ability to serve your communities."

3. Add fun to the workday

Try these:

• Start a walking club
• Offer lunchtime yoga
• Plan team-building activities

4. Train your leaders

Teach managers to:

• Spot burnout signs
• Talk about mental health
• Keep teams motivated

Working with limited funds

Nearly 90% of nonprofits run on less than $500,000 a year. That makes it tough to compete with for-profit salaries. But money isn't everything. Here's what you can do:

1. Offer flexible work

Over 35% of employees would choose flexible hours over a pay raise. Almost 10% would take a pay cut for flexibility.

2. Focus on benefits that matter

3. Provide growth opportunities

Lack of advancement is a top reason people leave. Offer:

• Training programs
• Mentorship
• Leadership roles on projects

4. Create a positive workplace

Make your nonprofit a great place to work:

• Have supportive managers
• Use good tools and software
• Consider on-site childcare

Keeping your best people isn't just about money. It's about creating a place where they want to stay and grow.

Conclusion

Keeping top talent in nonprofits isn't just about money. It's about creating a workplace where people want to stay and grow. Here's what works:

Growth opportunities: 44% of nonprofit workers who left in 2021 cited lack of career growth. Offer clear paths for advancement and learning.

Fair pay and benefits: Budgets are tight, so focus on what matters most to employees. Flexible work hours can beat a raise for many.

Positive workplace: Build a culture that supports your team and connects to your mission. This fights burnout and keeps people engaged.

Recognition: Show appreciation for good work. It costs nothing but means everything.

Mentoring: Set up programs to help employees grow. People stay 41% longer at organizations with strong internal mobility.

Tech tools: Use technology to keep staff connected and make their jobs easier.

Investing in these strategies pays off big time for nonprofits:

Related posts

• Predictive Analytics for Nonprofits: Boost Donor Retention
• Mastering the Art of Donor Retention: 5 Proven Techniques
• Innovative Engagement Tactics to Keep Sponsors Invested in Your Cause
• The Future of Nonprofit Sponsorships: Trends and Predictions